Honestly, Martha’s Vineyard isn’t cheap. But if you know where to look, some Martha’s Vineyard rentals, MA, are actually worth every penny.
The secret?
It’s all about what you get for the price. Not every rental is just four walls and a bed. The ones that stand out give you location, comfort, and thoughtful extras that make your trip easier, more relaxing, and way more enjoyable.
What Makes a Rental Worth the Price?
First, let’s talk value.
A good rental has more than just clean sheets and working plumbing. You’re looking for things like proximity to the beach, modern kitchens, outdoor decks for grilling or relaxing, and extras like bikes, beach chairs, and outdoor showers. Rentals that include those extras can save you from renting gear or dragging sandy stuff back to a hotel.
Now let’s break it down by budget. Because if you’re planning a simple family trip or a luxury week away, many rentals in MA fit your style and feel like money well spent.
Mid-Range Gems: Comfort Meets Convenience
Take our Katama House, for example. This two-bedroom classic is located at the end of a private road, just two miles from downtown Edgartown and minutes from South Beach. For about $2500–$4200 a week, depending on the season, you get a modern kitchen with granite countertops, comfy furnishings, a private deck with a gas grill, and even a king-size bed with skylights and a balcony.
There’s also an outdoor shower and beach access nearby. For a mid-range price, this place gives you space, quiet, and island charm.
Then there’s the Surfside Cottage, a three-bedroom house with central A/C, a huge modern kitchen, and a wraparound second-floor deck. It’s great for families or groups, especially those who want the feel of a beach house without paying luxury prices.
These Martha’s Vineyard rentals in MA are the sweet spot for travelers who want location, comfort, and amenities.
Luxury Stays That Are Totally Worth It
Now let’s talk premium. Not all high-end rentals are the same, but the ones that justify the price come with thoughtful extras, big backyards, and room for the whole crew.
Our Vineyard House is a great example. With three bedrooms and space for eight, it’s best for family reunions, wedding guests, or friend groups. You’ll get cathedral ceilings, skylights, a massive 60-inch TV in the living room, and a modern kitchen with granite counters. Plus, it’s located close to Morning Glory Farm and South Beach.
We also have a Martha’s Vineyard House, which combines charm with modern upgrades. Three bedrooms, spacious common areas, cathedral ceilings, and a deck perfect for evening BBQs. It’s not cheap, but it sleeps up to eight and includes features like three queen beds, multiple TVs, and a fully stocked kitchen.
These high-end Martha’s Vineyard rentals in MA are worth the price if you’re planning something special, or you just want the space and quiet to really relax.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to Martha’s Vineyard rentals, MA, value is about more than price. It’s about location, comfort, convenience, and whether your rental makes the rest of your vacation easy.
The rentals we provide are locally owned and managed by Sandra and Paul Bonetti. They’ve been doing this since the early ’80s, and they know what makes a vacation rental actually worth booking.
So, are you ready to book? Browse the full list of our rentals, and book your favorite place today!
